Unique Magic the Gathering Gifts for Fans - Beyond the Game Table

If you’ve ever stood in the card aisle at your local game store, thinking, “I know they already have almost every pack of cards ever printed, so what do I buy them?” then congratulations. You are officially in the same existential dread zone as many MTG gift-givers on the planet. If you’re searching for unique Magic The Gathering gifts for fans, you’ve come to the right place.

Fear not, fellow planeswalker. We’ve assembled a spellbook of gifts that don’t just live in the library of your average deck box. These are gifts that are stylish, fun, collectable, and useful. For newbies and veterans alike, we're sure you'll find something here that won't get counterspelled.

This isn’t your average “buy a pack, hope for a mythic” list. No, we’re talking about gifts that hit harder than a Lightning Bolt, stick around longer than Pacify and spark joy like a freshly played Black Lotus. From hilarious mugs that challenge your besties' deck-building skills, to fan art posters that tap into your inner planeswalker, these gifts are sure to draw a smile faster than you can say ‘top-decked a Sol Ring.

So grab your commander, sharpen your wits, and let’s dive into 10 Magic The Gathering Gifts beyond the game table.

1. Tap for Coffee Mug – Activate Your Morning Mana

Who says you can’t start your morning by tapping your mana? The Tap for Coffee Mug is perfect for the planeswalker who needs their caffeine boost before a tournament, or before unleashing that combo deck at the kitchen table. Sleek, humorous, and stylish, this mug doesn’t just hold your drink; it taps into their inner mana pool.

Why it’s a great gift idea beyond cards:

• Practical: perfect for coffee, tea, or any morning potion

• Humorous: adds a clever MTG twist to everyday life

• Thoughtful: shows you understand their love for Magic beyond cards

2. Black Lotus Pop Art Poster – Iconic Art Meets Pop Culture

Some cards belong in a museum, and the Black Lotus Pop Art Poster is one of them. This isn’t just wall decor, it’s a declaration. A reminder that your favourite MTG fan has taste, style, and probably a few stories about the time they actually held one when they were 8 years old

Why it’s awesome:

• Bold pop-art style transforms the iconic Black Lotus into a statement piece

• Perfect for game rooms, dorms, or anywhere you want to remind your friends you play Magic like a pro

• Conversation starter for guests who may not “get” the glory of MTG

3. MTG Party Printables – Planeswalker-Level Party Props

Why stop at tapping mana when you can tap into party mode? The MTG Party Printables are perfect for the fan who wants to bring their love of Magic into every celebration. From birthdays to game nights, these printables turn any gathering into a legendary event that even Jace would approve of. Instagrammable worthy and just good fun.

Why it's a unique gift:

• 10 Fully themed MTG party props.

• Easy to download and print, instant magic for your game table.

• Perfect for fans of all ages who want a memorable, immersive MTG celebration

4. Black Lotus MTG Tote Bag – Carry Your Fandom Everywhere

Totes aren’t just for groceries anymore. The Black Lotus MTG Tote Bag is for the fan who wants their Magic fandom to travel beyond the table. It’s sturdy, stylish, and makes a subtle nod to the most iconic MTG card.

Why they'll love it:

• Subtle fan-culture design makes it suitable for daily use.

• Perfect for carrying deck boxes, dice, snacks, to your next gathering or just to look cool at the next pre-release

5. MTG-Themed Nope Poster - For Blue Wizards

Fans don’t just play Magic, they live it. And for the Blue players out there who live for counterspells, the MTG Nope Poster from Craftorb is an absolute must-have. This artwork is a perfect fit for any MTG fan who knows the power of a well-timed counter.

Highlights:

• Museum-Quality Paper: Printed on 240gsm smooth matte finish paper for a luxurious feel and stunning visual impact.

• High-Quality Giclée Print: Ensuring rich colours and sharp details that capture the MTG vibe.

6. MTG “Your Angel Deck Sucks But We Still Love You” Mug

Every MTG group has that one friend whose deck makes you laugh, groan, or shake your head in disbelief. Maybe it’s a deck that just barely works, or maybe it’s the one you secretly dread facing at Friday Night Magic. The MTG “Your Angel Deck Sucks But We Still Love You” mug celebrates that playful rivalry in a way only Magic players understand.

Great because:

• It's practical, stylish, and everyday-friendly.

• It's a perfect 'Joke' gift between friends.

• challenges their deck-building skills.

7. Magic The Gathering Birthday Card – Make Their Special Day Legendary

Sometimes, the best gifts aren’t the ones you just buy, they’re the ones that you can personalise and speak directly to the heart of a planeswalker. The Magic The Gathering Birthday Card from Craftorb lets you celebrate a fan’s special day with style and a touch of MTG magic. The editable Canva template lets you customise the card like you’re building the perfect deck, choose their favourite mana colour, tweak the design to match their style, and inscribe a personal message that hits harder than a Lightning Strike.

Why it’s a great gift idea:

• The editable Canva template lets you tailor the card to their favourite mana colour or deck style.

• A unique way to make birthdays feel legendary.

• Let's you write your own heartfelt or humorous message.

• Ideal for anyone who loves MTG, from casual players to veteran planeswalkers.

8. MTG Ceramic Christmas Tree Decoration – Deck Your Halls Like a Planeswalker

Sometimes, MTG fans want to celebrate their love of the game all year round, and that includes the holiday season. The MTG Ceramic Christmas Tree Decoration from Craftorb lets them add a touch of Magic to their festive décor, combining geeky charm with seasonal cheer. It’s perfect for fans who want their holidays to feel like a mini multiverse of fun.

Why It Works:

• A unique, collectable ceramic decoration with MTG-inspired Mana Tree design

• Perfect for Christmas trees, shelves, or as a stocking filler.

9. MTG Bring the Fire Poster – Red Mana Gift

Want to bring the heat from the battlefield into your home? The Bring the Fire Poster is a must-have for any fan of red-mana chaos, burn decks, or just the thrill of watching your Goblin horde sweep the table. It’s a declaration: you play fast, you play hard, and you bring the fire.

Why it’s awesome:

• Speaks to the souls of all Burn players - like, you get them!

• High-quality print

• Unique design - you won't find this on Amazon!

10. MTG Commander Tracker – Fillable PDF Planner

Keep your games in check and your brain from turning into a chaotic mess with this MTG Commander Tracker. Perfect for fans who already own every card under the sun, this isn’t another booster pack; it’s a digital gift that actually helps improve the game.

With 16 fillable PDF planners, it’s like giving your friend a personal assistant who never complains, never forgets commander damage, token counts, or life totals, and always keeps the game running smoothly. Let’s face it: Commander games can spiral into chaos, and this tracker keeps everything under control while letting players focus on the fun… not the math.

Why It Makes A Great Gift Beyond Cards:

• Unique and practical: Not another deck box or dice set, this is something they’ll actually use every commander game night.

• Customisable for any deck: Track life, commander damage, counters, and even upload your commander card image for a personal touch.

• Instant digital download: No waiting, no shipping, just immediate organisation for their next game.

• Perfect for all levels: From casual EDH fans to veteran commanders who love keeping their board state under control.

Wrapping It All Up: Why These Gifts Work

Let’s face it, buying non-card gifts for an MTG fan can sometimes feel overwhelming. Hopefully, these ideas can make your choice a little less stressful. They tick the following boxes;

• Practical: Mugs and tote bags are daily-use gifts. No collecting dust here.

• Stylish: Art prints, pop art posters, turn rooms into mini-battlefields of fandom.

• Customisable: Editable Canva templates allow personalisation for a truly unique gift.

• Memorable: Bundles and curated items make an impression, ensuring you’ll be remembered long after the last booster pack has been opened.

  
  

You’re not just buying a gift. You’re giving the kind of MTG experience that hits like a properly timed Wrath of God: impactful, appreciated, and absolutely unforgettable.

So, what are you waiting for? Whether they’re a brand-new planeswalker or a seasoned EDH legend, these Craftorb items will make you the ultimate MTG gift-giver. Your MTG friend will thank you, your gift-giving reputation will soar higher than an Emrakul, and you’ll finally know the joy of buying a gift that doesn’t just fill space—it levels up their game!

Not sure what an Editable Canva Template is? This short guide will walk you through it step-by-step.